Result dialog after a solved or failed Puzzle, and the Puzzle's rating once resolved #453

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-10-19 14:45:43 +00:00 by root · 11 comments

root commented

2026-10-19 14:45:43 +00:00

(Migrated from gitlab.core-project.space)

Parent

#450

What to build

API. The solved and failed move results and the solution result gain the Puzzle's own rating. ServedPuzzle does not carry it, so it never reaches the page before the Puzzle is resolved.

Result dialog. A dialog opens when a Puzzle is solved or failed on the board, in an Attempt or a Replay. Hint and Show solution never open it.

Solved, rated: "Solved!", the new Puzzle rating with its change, and Review and Next.
Failed, rated: the right Move in SAN, the new Puzzle rating with its change, and Review, Retry and Next.
Solved or failed Replay: "Unrated: your Puzzle rating does not change" in place of the rating line.
Next is the focused, primary action.
Review, Close and Escape leave the board and the move list as the Puzzle ended.

Puzzle row. Once the Puzzle is resolved by any ending, including Show solution, the Puzzle row reveals the Puzzle's rating.

Covers stories 19 and 32–35.

Seam: Front — the pages on the app's router, for the dialog and the row. The Puzzle's rating in the results goes through the API seam as widened on #450 (the puzzle.* procedures through the RPC integration harness).

Acceptance criteria

RPC integration tests: solved, failed and solution carry the Puzzle's rating; next and replay do not
The dialog opens on each of the four endings with the content above, and never after a Hint or Show solution
Retry starts a Replay of the same Puzzle; Next serves the next one
The Puzzle row shows "hidden" until the Puzzle is resolved, then the Puzzle's rating
puzzles.spec.ts asserts the dialog and its rating change on the solve and on the failure
Browser check of the four dialog states at 390, 1280 and 1920 px, with screenshots in the merge request

## Parent #450 ## What to build **API.** The `solved` and `failed` move results and the `solution` result gain the Puzzle's own rating. `ServedPuzzle` does not carry it, so it never reaches the page before the Puzzle is resolved. **Result dialog.** A dialog opens when a Puzzle is solved or failed on the board, in an Attempt or a Replay. Hint and Show solution never open it. - Solved, rated: "Solved!", the new Puzzle rating with its change, and Review and Next. - Failed, rated: the right Move in SAN, the new Puzzle rating with its change, and Review, Retry and Next. - Solved or failed Replay: "Unrated: your Puzzle rating does not change" in place of the rating line. - Next is the focused, primary action. - Review, Close and Escape leave the board and the move list as the Puzzle ended. **Puzzle row.** Once the Puzzle is resolved by any ending, including Show solution, the Puzzle row reveals the Puzzle's rating. Covers stories 19 and 32–35. Seam: Front — the pages on the app's router, for the dialog and the row. The Puzzle's rating in the results goes through the API seam as widened on #450 (the `puzzle.*` procedures through the RPC integration harness). ## Acceptance criteria - [ ] RPC integration tests: `solved`, `failed` and `solution` carry the Puzzle's rating; `next` and `replay` do not - [ ] The dialog opens on each of the four endings with the content above, and never after a Hint or Show solution - [ ] Retry starts a Replay of the same Puzzle; Next serves the next one - [ ] The Puzzle row shows "hidden" until the Puzzle is resolved, then the Puzzle's rating - [ ] `puzzles.spec.ts` asserts the dialog and its rating change on the solve and on the failure - [ ] Browser check of the four dialog states at 390, 1280 and 1920 px, with screenshots in the merge request

root commented

2026-10-19 14:46:30 +00:00

(Migrated from gitlab.core-project.space)

mentioned in issue #457